Dolly Parton made a lot of things across her 60-plus-year career: massive hit songs, a theme park, a children’s literacy initiative that gave away over 300 million books, movies of both thesmash-hitandcult classicvariety. But she shied away from making political statements.
This might seem like an odd thing to say about a country star whose coiffed blonde wig inched close to the heavenly host up until her death on Monday at 80, a down-home diva whose songs made her identifiable by just a mononym, whose blindingly bedazzled, highly structured outfits made her recognized by just her silhouette. Parton preferred to let her closet make the statements, while quietly building a kind of everybody-love-everybody progressivism that promoted equality and kindness while remaining mostly off-the-record.
In the public eye, Parton the person was always willing to take a backseat to her persona. She turned the “dumb blonde” assumptions on the audience, crafting a comedic alter ego that happened to share her name. Although it was Dolly Parton taking questions from late-night hosts in countless, breezy interviews, it was “Dolly Parton” answering. Dolly the characterwasn’t taken seriously, and that steered interviewers away from asking her about serious topics.
Though she consciously and strenuously attempted toavoid labels
Though she consciously and strenuously attempted toavoid labels like feminist and activist, Parton’s actions occasionally made her inner beliefs undeniable. She was writing songsin support of gay family membersback in 1991, the first mainstream country artist to do so. She took aride on the Magic School Busin 1996 to stress the importance of recycling and environmental conservation. You can find her on the cover ofOut Magazine in 1997, celebrating her legions of LGBTQ fans. Here she comes again, penning a song for the 2005 movie “Transamerica” that would go on to receive an Academy Award nomination. And there you go, trying to make the “love is love” ethos of her public persona into something like a personal politics.
But Parton could be hard to pin down. She’s the centerpiece of “9 to 5,” a movie about unionization and pushing back against workplace sexual harassment. If you somehow missed that star turn — her first — don’t worry; she sings the theme song. Still, shequickly shut downElizabeth Warren’s presidential campaign in 2019 when they attempted to use “9 to 5” at rallies as a nod to the candidate’s pro-labor activism. Parton repeatedlyrefused to acceptthe Presidential Medal of Freedom from both Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Buried somewhere in her reasoning was likely something along these lines: “Dolly Parton” isn’t political, therefore Dolly Parton’s songs cannot be political.
The singer’s extensive philanthropic record mostlypushed the importance of literacyand higher education, a view that has been coded as left-of-center thanks to the actions of Republicans, who have spentseveral decadesfleeing and sometimes sabotaging public education. Parton’s AIDS activism andLGBTQ advocacyputs her well to the left of the average MAGA fan socially. Despite this, she’s universally adored across the political spectrum. Apollreleased just this April found she had the highest favorability ratings of any American.
How was this country legend able to walk
How was this country legend able to walk the line so deftly? Why was she able to work toward progressive goals without facing any backlash from conservative fans? And will any mainstream country star ever be able to avoid gettingbogged down in culture war battlesthe way Dolly did?
That last question is the easiest and quickest to answer: No. The why is less simple.
Dolly was able to just be Dolly, in part, because of how long she’d been Dolly. She predated our overheated era of cable-news slapfights as a massive star and national treasure who never took herself too seriously.
Dolly wasable to just be Dolly, in part,
Dolly wasable to just be Dolly, in part, because of how long she’d been Dolly. She predated our overheated era of cable-news slapfights as a massive star and national treasure who never took herself too seriously. She was famously in on all the jokes about her.She launched her Imagination Library in the late 1980s, well before a time when a centralized charity sending out books directly to children would be subject to immense scrutiny, outside offringe crankson high alert for any whiff of a New World Order. Parton was cemented as an icon before two events turned country music stardom entirely on its head.
TheSept. 11 attacksand the advent of social media fundamentally changed the shape of country music and what it meant to be a chart-topper. The latter gave rise to the idea that fans had a right to know more about their favorite artists, up to and including where they stood on specific political issues. The former was the genesis of the Global War on Terror, an atrocity that drew a red line through American culture and bluntly asked a question familiar to Parton’s fellow Appalachians:Which side are you on?
In the aftermath of 9/11, country music radio became a font of rah-rah troop support and war-boosterism. AsLee Greenwood’s 1984 hit “God Bless The U.S.A.”returned to the chart, 1990s hitmaker Alan Jackson took a break from tender love songs to write aschmaltzy tributeto the lives lost at Ground Zero, the Pentagon and the field in Pennsylvania. Toby Keith drooled over artillery and warned “we’ll put a boot in your a*s, it’s the American way,” and Darryl Worleywrote propaganda piecesfor the war’s expansion. The jingoism soonbecame all too much for The Chicks, the best-selling country band in recorded history, whose frontwoman Natalie Maines said during a London show kicking off the band’s “Top of the World” tour that she was “ashamed” then-President George W. Bush was from her home state of Texas. “We do not want this war, this violence,” she said, referring to the administration’s imminent plans to invade Iraq.
(Mario Villafuerte/) Shreveport, Louisiana, country radio personality K
(Mario Villafuerte/) Shreveport, Louisiana, country radio personality K. C. Daniels turned a poster of The Chicks into a dartboard in March 2003 following lead singer Natalie Maines’ comments about President George W. Bush and Iraq at a concert in London
The backlash was swift and immediate. Knee-jerk patriots who felt betrayed by these bluegrass traditionalists turned mega-starscrushed their Chicks’ CDsin public protests. They argued that Maines’ criticism, which came on foreign soil, was cowardly. Maines countered that she was responding to current events, but she apologized to the fans who felt hurt — and then she recanted. The Chicks’ songs were blacklisted on many country radio stations, and remained that way for years. While the band never wavered on their criticism of Bush, and even doubled down on it in their 2006 hit “Not Ready to Make Nice,” the message was clear to any acts without the mega-fame of The Chicks: Shut up and sing.
The resulting two decades of conservative, nostalgic hits on country radio have made Republican leanings cloaked in back-home nostalgia the default pose of country music’s A-list. At the same time, fan pressure to offer unambiguous political statements has grown.
Parton’s solo career spanned equally divisive times, launching
Parton’s solo career spanned equally divisive times, launching at the height of the Vietnam War and carrying on for everything that came afterwards. But the assumption that she should have a stance on issues of the day was nowhere near as strong then. By the time social mediamade political heat checks commonplace, Parton was exempt from the demand for answers.
Start your day with essential news from Salon.
Sign up for our free morning newsletter, Crash Course.
Maybe it’s because journalists and fans knew what they would get. In a May 2023 interview with journalist Jacob Saboroff, she was asked about what could well be her most political song. “World on Fire,” she sang, “Greedy politicians present and past / They wouldn’t know the truth if it bit ‘em in the a*s.” Parton told Soboroff she was singing about “All of ‘em. Any of ‘em.”
I don’t think any of ‘em are trying
“I don’t think any of ‘em are trying hard enough,” she said. “I’m sure we’re all trying, but I just really think often that they worry more about their party than they do about the people. If we just do what we felt was the right thing, rather than who’s going to lose, or who’s going to win this, or who’s going to look better if they do this. None of them are working from the heart.”
At the same time, allegations of GOP sympathies dogged country star turned pop icon Taylor Swift for years before she explicitly endorsed Democratic candidate Kamala Harris for president in 2024. IfZac BrownandLuke Bryanwere going to turn the charts into troops salutes and MAGA boat parade soundtracks, then actual veteran Zach Bryan was going to have to go on the record with ananti-ICE track. Although Kacey Musgraves hassingles in the Parton schoolof “let people live,” she doesn’t have the luxury of public neutrality that Dolly did.
Our Summer sale ends August 31!
Premium members read ad-free and save 58%. Join now
Now even Dolly-esque clowning can’t save country music’s current stars from having to take unambiguous positions. In the music video for Musgraves’ recent single “Dry Spell,” she reflects on striking out as a single woman while ogling suggestively shaped produce in the grocery store. On her current tour, she descends to the stage on a pair of mirror-covered testicles, literal disco balls. Still, when she speaks out in support of American immigrants as one of the genre’s most prominent progressives, she’sbranded a traitorby conservative country fans. Musgraves’ fanbase wants her to speak up, if only to distance herself from the MAGA-until-proven-otherwise pack, but doing so is risky and messy.
No such backlash came for Dolly when she
No such backlash came for Dolly when she spoke outagainst Tennessee’s anti-trans lawsor insupport of the George Floyd protests. She was able to hold a consistent “play nice” line because of her unassailable career and how long she’d been at it. It’s a stance that wouldn’t be allowed from anyone but Dolly, and one that will now almost certainly never be accepted again. Like her rise from the deepest rural poverty to beloved multi-millionaire, it’s one more yet part of her story that is entirely singular.
- Dolly Parton’s TV specials showed her sparkle was universal
- Gillian Welch’s “Everything Is Free” warned us all along
- At 80, Dolly Parton remains our most unlikely national unifier
The post Dolly Parton blazed a path that modern country stars can’t follow appeared first on Salon.com.
Source: www.salon.com
